Notes, summaries, assignments, exams, and problems for Philosophy and ethics

Citizenship: Greek and Roman Origins to Modern Concepts

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.87 KB

1. Origin of the Concept of Citizenship

1.1. A Standard Definition

Citizen: An inhabitant of ancient cities and a modern political and legal subject involved in governing the country. Citizenship appears to have the following features:

  • Membership in a political community that resides permanently in a territory.
  • The enjoyment of rights that must be protected by the city, including the possibility of participating in the work of government.

1.2. Citizenship in Greco-Roman Antiquity

The term "citizen" comes from the Latin civis, a word that shares the same root as civitas (city-state). The term civis was reserved for those community members who met certain requirements. The rest of the population was not considered citizens.

In ancient Greece, the term...

Continue reading "Citizenship: Greek and Roman Origins to Modern Concepts" »

Heraclitus vs Parmenides: Philosophical Perspectives on Change and Being

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.03 KB

Philosophical Differences: Heraclitus vs. Parmenides

Stance Toward the World

  • Heraclitus: The world is in a state of perpetual becoming; it is dynamic, not static.
  • Parmenides: The world is static; there is no becoming.

The Nature of Truth

  • Heraclitus: As a consequence of constant change, the road to truth reflects this perpetual flux.
  • Parmenides: The road to truth is singular and unchanging.

The Stance on Being

  • Heraclitus: Being is the essence of things, yet it can both be and not be, as everything is in flux.
  • Parmenides: Being is the true essence of things. The existence of being and non-being appears only to the vulgar; in the way of truth, only Being manifests.

The Essence of the World

  • Heraclitus: The essence cannot be grasped due to constant change;
...
Continue reading "Heraclitus vs Parmenides: Philosophical Perspectives on Change and Being" »

Nietzsche: Becoming, Eternal Recurrence and Amor Fati

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.89 KB

Nietzschean Philosophy: Becoming, Will to Power, and Eternal Recurrence

1. The Innocence of Becoming: Change and Reality

The concept of **Becoming** (remember **Heraclitus**), or change and dialectic, is entirely innocent, representing what has not yet been invested or changed by values. This process of becoming is the only reality—life itself, the history of humanity, this world that becomes, as there is no other world.

Platonic Stagnation vs. Dynamic Reality

Philosophers, due to their lack of historical sense, have mummified (preserving something dead as if it were alive) everything they touched, thus inventing the "highest concepts." This tendency is their *Egipticismo* (one of two idiosyncrasies).

According to philosophers, starting with Plato,...

Continue reading "Nietzsche: Becoming, Eternal Recurrence and Amor Fati" »

Key Legal Principles: Non-Retroactivity, Res Judicata, Prescription, Common Good

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.4 KB

Principle of Non-Retroactivity of Law

The principle of non-retroactivity of law means that a law can only apply to the future and will never have a retroactive effect. However, there are laws that apply retroactively. For example, laws that restrict themselves to declaring the meaning of other laws shall be incorporated into them but will not, in any way, affect the effects of judgments enforceable in the intermediate time.

Principle of Res Judicata

Res judicata is the effect produced by certain court decisions that are immovable, i.e., they cannot be discussed again. The principle of res judicata requires compliance with what was fixed in the sentence and also prevents double jeopardy by prohibiting the repetition of what has already been decided....

Continue reading "Key Legal Principles: Non-Retroactivity, Res Judicata, Prescription, Common Good" »

Nietzsche: Revaluation of Values and Nihilism

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.31 KB

Nietzsche's Revaluation of Values

Critique of Existing Morality

Nietzsche argued that humanity is often despicable and corrupted, primarily due to its false table of values or axiological hierarchy. He proposed the following principles:

  • The Transmutation of All Values: We must replace current values with others that elevate us beyond spiritual poverty.
  • Critique of Metaphysical Notions: Current values are often based on non-existent entities (e.g., God, truth). Their absence offers no guidance for humanity, leading to hypocrisy.
  • The Will to Power: Our most immediate reality is our desire for power. Our actions are governed by instincts, with the will to power as the primary drive.
  • Affirmation of Life: Life itself is inherently good and exuberant.
...
Continue reading "Nietzsche: Revaluation of Values and Nihilism" »

St. Augustine's World: Rome's Decline, Christian Disputes and Neoplatonism

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.81 KB

The Historical and Intellectual World of St. Augustine

Historical Context: The Decline of Rome

St. Augustine, born around 354 CE, lived during an age of profound upheaval. The Roman Empire began its marked decline during this period, spanning the reigns of emperors like Julian and Theodosius I. It was Theodosius I who, in 380 CE, declared Nicene Christianity the official religion of the empire (via the Edict of Thessalonica), effectively neutralizing polytheism and forcing all imperial structures to adapt to a new way of thinking.

This shift led to complex relations between philosophy and religion:

  • Philosophy: Seeks to explain human dilemmas rationally and through common sense.
  • Religion: Bases solutions to human dilemmas in faith and belief statements
...
Continue reading "St. Augustine's World: Rome's Decline, Christian Disputes and Neoplatonism" »

Ortega y Gasset: The Doctrine of the Point of View and Its Philosophical Context

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 2.41 KB

The Doctrine of the Point of View

Links to Other Philosophical Positions

The theory of knowledge in Plato's doctrine opposes Ortega's perspectivism. Plato provides two basic classes of knowledge: episteme (true knowledge) and doxa (opinion). For Plato, real knowledge is episteme, while perspective resides in opinion and fails to reach true knowledge.

For Thomas Aquinas, it is possible to obtain an understanding of the essence of things from their sensible manifestations; this is the doctrine of abstraction.

For Marx, men are the producers of their own ideas, conditioned by their material reality. Ortega agrees with Marx that a perspective is a product of specific circumstances, but argues that this perspective does not distort reality; rather,...

Continue reading "Ortega y Gasset: The Doctrine of the Point of View and Its Philosophical Context" »

Kant's Historical Context: Enlightenment and Prussian Rule in the 18th Century

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.12 KB

Immanuel Kant's Historical Context (18th Century)

Kant lived for much of the eighteenth century, a period of relative calm following the previous era called the Wars of Religion and preceding a series of Revolutionary Wars (American and French). In this interwar period, the European intellectual elite perceived a common mentality produced by a shared belief in a set of values that has passed into history with the name of the artwork.

The Intellectual Climate: Revolution of Minds

This common mentality, rather than producing political change, sought to achieve a general revolution in minds, illustrating the rulers and educating people so that they could improve the law and realize the idea of progress. This notion of revolution of thought and education...

Continue reading "Kant's Historical Context: Enlightenment and Prussian Rule in the 18th Century" »

French Revolution: Individualism, Sovereignty, and the Rejection of Historicism

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 3.37 KB

Revolutions and Doctrines of Freedom

Individualism and Privatism

  • Privatism: Individualism can result in an economic situation where the common political foundation is only and exclusively a contractual guarantee or mutual insurance relationship between individual owners.
  • There is a possible degeneration of individualism into a voluntaristic contractual sense, where all political outcomes become dependent variables of the individual citizens' will.

The French Revolution (1788–1794)

After several events occurring between 1788 and 1794, the French Revolution was reached. We witness the formation of a culture of freedom that results from a combination of the individualistic and contractarian model and the state, deliberately leaving out the historicist...

Continue reading "French Revolution: Individualism, Sovereignty, and the Rejection of Historicism" »

Saint Augustine: Reason, Faith, and the Path to Truth

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 2.4 KB

Saint Augustine: The Harmony of Reason and Faith

Saint Augustine posits that reason and faith are two distinct paths that converge at the same destination: knowledge. Because there is only one truth, these two actions are complementary and collaborative, summarized by the principle: "Believe to comprehend, and understand to believe."

The Theory of Knowledge and Interiority

Augustine’s epistemology is rooted in self-reflection to reach God. He is the first philosopher to emphasize that we seek truth within ourselves rather than in the imperfect material world. Our reason is guided by eternal ideas, which originate from the mind of God, illuminating our intellect so we may grasp the truth.

Human Nature and the Soul

Man, created in the image and...

Continue reading "Saint Augustine: Reason, Faith, and the Path to Truth" »