European Political Systems: Absolutism to Constitutionalism
Classified in History
Written on in 
English with a size of 5.48 KB
Historical Political Systems Compared
Explore the defining characteristics of Absolutism, Parliamentary Systems, and Enlightened Despotism, three pivotal political models that shaped European history. This comparison highlights their core principles, power structures, and societal impacts.
| Feature | Absolutism | Parliamentary System | Enlightened Despotism |
|---|---|---|---|
| Century | 17th Century | 17th-18th Century | 18th Century |
| Key Saying | "L'état, c'est moi!" (The state, it is I!) | - | "Everything for the people, but nothing by the people." |
| Power Structure | Monarch held absolute power, from the smallest village to the Palace of Versailles. | Power shared between the monarchy and the parliament. | Monarch held unlimited power, often justified by reason. |
| Justification | Divine Right of Kings: God placed the monarch in power; all power came from God. | Popular Sovereignty: People held ultimate power but allowed the monarch to rule. | Divine Appointment: The monarch was appointed by God, but ruled with enlightened principles. |
| Primary Locations | France (especially) and most countries in Europe. | United Kingdom. | Most countries that did not develop the parliamentary model (e.g., Prussia, Austria, Russia). |
| Level of Democracy | No level of democracy. | High level of democracy, though limited by the monarch's rule. | No direct democracy; reforms from above. |
| Social Groups Supported | Nobles and the Church. | Bourgeoisie, wealthy members of the Third Estate. | Nobles and the Church, often with support from intellectuals. |
The Parliamentary System: Evolution and Impact
The parliamentary system emerged as a distinct alternative to absolutism, particularly in England, driven by socio-economic changes and evolving political thought. Its development laid the groundwork for modern democratic governance.
Rise of the Bourgeoisie
A prosperous middle class, the bourgeoisie, sought greater freedom and political power. Their economic influence grew, leading to demands for a voice in governance and a challenge to traditional aristocratic privileges.
Influence of Protestantism
Protestantism, a key ideological origin, encouraged hard work and the belief that labor could lead to salvation. This contrasted with the Catholic Church's emphasis on obedience, fostering a spirit of individual initiative and questioning of authority that contributed to the demand for political reform.
Power Sharing and Governance
Power was shared between the monarchy and the parliament, primarily in England and Ireland. The monarchy held executive power and applied laws, while Parliament passed laws and held legislative power. This division of power was a significant departure from absolute rule.
The Magna Carta (1215) was a foundational document that established early rights and limited the monarch's power, setting a precedent for constitutional governance.
English Civil War and the First Republic
The 17th century saw a profound conflict in England: the English Civil War (1642-1651). This was a struggle between Catholic nobles (Royalists), who supported the king, and Protestant bourgeoisie (Parliamentarians), who advocated for parliamentary supremacy. The Parliamentarians won, establishing a Republic under Oliver Cromwell for six years (1649-1660) before the monarchy was restored. This period demonstrated the growing power of Parliament and the limits of royal authority.
Habeas Corpus Act (1679)
This act established the fundamental right of an arrested person to appear before a judge with legal counsel to challenge their detention. It was a significant reaction against absolutism, protecting individual liberties from arbitrary state power.
Bill of Rights (1689)
Considered the first modern constitution, the Bill of Rights significantly limited royal power and established parliamentary supremacy. Many fundamental human rights were enshrined within it, serving as a precursor to the French Revolution's ideals and influencing constitutionalism worldwide. Key rights included:
- Freedom of Speech (within Parliament)
- Habeas Corpus
- Free Elections (for Parliament)
- No taxation without parliamentary consent
- No standing army in peacetime without parliamentary consent
Case Studies of Parliamentary Development
The Netherlands: A Parliamentary Republic
Initially a parliamentary republic composed of seven provinces, each with its own parliament, the Netherlands showcased an early model of decentralized governance. It later became a monarchy, which it remains today, demonstrating an evolution from republicanism to constitutional monarchy.
Poland: Elected Monarchy and Partition
Poland had an elected monarchy, chosen by its nobility. While seemingly democratic, this system led to internal conflicts among nobles and weakened the central government. This internal instability ultimately resulted in the partitions of Poland by neighboring powers like Russia, Prussia (Germany), and Austria in the late 18th century, ending its independence.