Notes, summaries, assignments, exams, and problems for Law & Jurisprudence

Symbolic Speech and Expression

• Protected Symbolic Speech

  • Tinker v. Des Moines (1969): Students wearing armbands to peacefully protest the Vietnam War were protected because their actions did not interfere with educational processes.
  • Texas v. Johnson (1989): Flag burning was protected as expressive conduct conveying a clear political message.
  • R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul (1992): A ban on cross burning was deemed too broad, as it prohibited speech based on its content rather than its potential for harm.

• Unprotected Symbolic Speech

  • United States v. O'Brien (1968): Burning a draft card was not protected because it involved the destruction of government property and interfered with a legitimate government interest.
  • Virginia v. Black (2003): Cross burning

The ESMA Case: Powers of EU Agencies

ESMA Case

Problems with EU agencies include a lack of democratic legitimacy and the fact that they do not have normative powers. (The two sources of democratic legitimacy are the European Parliament and the Council of the EU, together with the European Council.) The EU still needs agencies because of the level of expertise required.

Facts

• The "ESMA Regulation" gave powers to ESMA to “prohibit some financial activities that threaten the financial markets or the stability.”
• Later, “the Regulation” further increased powers – Article 28 of the Regulation allowed ESMA to intervene with short sale transactions if it thinks that there is a threat to the functioning and stability of a financial market or the

Baseball’s free agent era was created by the Supreme Court’s ruling in the Curt Flood case.

Define the term monopoly: A market situation where one producer (or a group of producers acting in concert) controls the supply of a good or service, and where the entry of new producers is prevented or highly restricted.

Name the federal antitrust laws that have a substantial impact on sports: Competition law.

Name two of the exemptions from antitrust laws that have been used in the sports industry: Baseball's antitrust exemption and the broadcasting exemption in the Sports Broadcasting Act.

Provide an example of a sports league rule that has become the subject of antitrust litigation because of accusations that the rules are too restrictive: Professional

Defining EU Citizenship and Belonging

Citizenship encompasses both legal status and the affective dimension of belonging within a political community.

EU Citizen Population

The European Union currently encompasses approximately 450 million citizens.

Fundamental Elements of Citizenship

• Contractual: Legal and constitutional elements reinforcing mutual obligations.
• Historical: A shared past, often summarized by the concept of Civis Romanus sum (I am a Roman citizen).
• Ontological: The identity and affective dimension of civic identity and belonging.
• Normative: The established standards and rules governing citizenship.

Key Rights for European Union Citizens

Established by Article 20 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU)

1. Right to Petition

   Citizens

The Constitution (1789)

Article I: Legislative Branch – Makes Laws

This is the longest Article, containing 10 Sections. The Founders considered this branch the most important.

Section 1: Congress

Establishes Congress, which includes the House of Representatives.

Section 8: Federal Powers

Details the powers granted to the federal government (Enumerated or Delegated Powers), such as:

• Establishing the Navy and Army
• Borrowing and coining money
• Establishing the postal office
• Declaring war

Necessary and Proper Clause (Implied Powers)

Allows Congress to make any law deemed necessary and proper to carry out the previously listed powers. This clause is broad and stretches the powers of the federal government. Any "new power" linked must relate to a power already... Continue reading "US Constitution Articles: Legislative, Executive, Judicial Powers" »

CHAPTER 1

• Criminal justice system: comprises institutions, policies, and practices with the goal of social control and deterring crime through sanctions and rehabilitation

• Law enforcement: investigates crimes and apprehends individuals alleged to have committed crimes

• Courts: interprets and applies the law

• Corrections: incarceration in jails or prisons, in some cases consisting of supervision in the community, parole, or probation.

• If prosecutor files charges: plea bargain and a plea is taken, or goes to trial, or nolle prosequi (dismissal).

• Mala en se: behavior that is immoral and inherently wrong by nature and we would have known not to do this activity even if there had not been a law prohibiting it.

• Mala prohibita: behavior that constitutes an

Confessions and Self-Incrimination Protections

Fifth Amendment: Self-Incrimination

Any person in any proceeding may refuse to answer if it might incriminate them. Limitations:

• The privilege against self-incrimination does not apply to the compulsory disclosure of documents.
• It protects compelled testimony, not physical evidence (e.g., blood, writing samples, voice exemplars, hair samples).

The privilege is eliminated if:

• A grant of immunity is given (transactional immunity or use and derivative use immunity).
• The privilege is waived.

Testimony cannot be used against the defendant for impeachment purposes.

Confessions and Due Process

To be admissible, a confession must not be the product of coercive police conduct. Factors considered include:

1. Physical

1. Final call of ₹3 per share was yet to be made. Calculate the maximum discount at which these shares can be reissued. X Ltd. invited applications for 500, 12% debentures of ₹100 each at a 5% discount. These debentures were redeemable after five years at par. Applications for 600 debentures were received. Pro-rata allotment was made to all applications. Pass necessary journal entries for the debenture issue, assuming the whole amount was payable with application. P and Q, partners sharing profits and losses equally, had fixed capitals of ₹2,00,000 and ₹3,00,000, respectively. The partnership deed provided 12% p.a. interest on capital. For the year ended March 31, 2016, profits were distributed without providing interest on capital. Pass

Evidence Exclusion in Criminal Cases

The Exclusionary Rule prohibits the introduction of evidence obtained in violation of a defendant's constitutional rights in a criminal trial. This applies to violations of the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments.

Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Doctrine

Evidence derived from illegal government conduct is generally excluded. However, there are key exceptions:

1. Independent Source: Evidence discovered through a source separate from the illegal conduct.
2. Inevitable Discovery: Evidence that would have been discovered lawfully regardless of the illegal conduct.
3. Defendant's Intervening Acts: The defendant's own actions break the causal chain between the illegal conduct and the evidence.

This doctrine does not apply to:

1. Grand