Descartes' Cogito: Philosophical Critiques of the Self
Classified in Philosophy and ethics
Written on in English with a size of 3.52 KB
Philosophical Critiques of Descartes' "Cogito Ergo Sum"
Huet's Challenge to Cartesian Evidence
A critique, often attributed to Pierre Daniel Huet, questions the Cartesian "Cogito ergo sum." It posits that we cannot accept the existence of reason as self-evident if its establishment as the rule of evidence could have been manipulated by an evil genius.
Descartes' Answer: Descartes counters that reason is an intuitive truth that reveals itself; it does not merely validate a rule of evidence established on a provisional basis. On the contrary, finding that the existence of reason is an irrefutable truth is, in fact, legitimized by the rule of evidence (though, Descartes concedes, ultimately legitimized only by God).