Marxism vs. Anarchism: Key Differences and Impacts
Classified in History
Written at on English with a size of 3.71 KB.
Marxism and Anarchism: Revolutionary Ideologies of the 19th Century
Revolutionary ideologies emerged in the 19th century. These ideologies promoted working-class interests and aimed to transform society through a workers' revolution. The most important of these were Marxism and Anarchism.
Marxism
Marxism is a socialist ideology developed by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels based on their analysis of politics and the economy. It advocates for the destruction of capitalism and the establishment of a communist society. Key concepts include:
- Class struggle: The oppressed proletariat would organize themselves and struggle against their oppressors, the capitalist bourgeoisie. Their objective would be to gain political power.
- The dictatorship of the working classes: Once they had achieved political power, the working classes would establish a new social and political order.
- The communist economy: Private property (capitalism) would be abolished, along with the means of production.
- The communist society: The class-based society would disappear because everybody would have the same relationship with the means of production. Society would be equal and without classes.
Anarchism
Anarchism was first developed by Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, and its best-known advocate was Mikhail Bakunin. They supported the overthrow of capitalism via a social revolution. These were the main principles of anarchism:
- Individual freedom: People had to fight against any authority or institution that limited freedom, such as the state and the church.
- Direct action: Each citizen should represent himself or herself, so anarchists rejected political parties and elections.
- The abolition of private property: Society would be organized into independent communes.
Political Ideologies in 19th-Century Spain: Moderates vs. Progressives
Moderates | Progressives | |
---|---|---|
Sovereignty | Shared between the monarch and the Cortes, but with royal power strengthened | Popular sovereignty in Cortes and royal power reduced |
The Cortes | Bicameral: Congress (elected) and Senate (elected by the monarch) | Bicameral: both elected |
Suffrage | Limited male suffrage | Limited male suffrage with lower property requirement |
Access to power | Through elections and royal appointment | Through military coups |
Supporters | Nobility, Church, wealthy bourgeoisie | Middle and petite bourgeoisie |
Key Differences: Marxism vs. Anarchism
Marxists | Anarchists | |
---|---|---|
Organization | Socialist parties and trade unions | Opposed to political parties but in favor of revolutionary trade unions |
Method of protest | Strikes and the organization of workers into political parties | Any means, including violence |
State | Working-class controlled state | Opposed to the existence of the state |
Means of production | State-controlled | Directly controlled by the working class and peasants |