Marxism vs. Anarchism: Key Differences and Impacts

Classified in History

Written at on English with a size of 3.71 KB.

Marxism and Anarchism: Revolutionary Ideologies of the 19th Century

Revolutionary ideologies emerged in the 19th century. These ideologies promoted working-class interests and aimed to transform society through a workers' revolution. The most important of these were Marxism and Anarchism.

Marxism

Marxism is a socialist ideology developed by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels based on their analysis of politics and the economy. It advocates for the destruction of capitalism and the establishment of a communist society. Key concepts include:

  • Class struggle: The oppressed proletariat would organize themselves and struggle against their oppressors, the capitalist bourgeoisie. Their objective would be to gain political power.
  • The dictatorship of the working classes: Once they had achieved political power, the working classes would establish a new social and political order.
  • The communist economy: Private property (capitalism) would be abolished, along with the means of production.
  • The communist society: The class-based society would disappear because everybody would have the same relationship with the means of production. Society would be equal and without classes.

Anarchism

Anarchism was first developed by Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, and its best-known advocate was Mikhail Bakunin. They supported the overthrow of capitalism via a social revolution. These were the main principles of anarchism:

  • Individual freedom: People had to fight against any authority or institution that limited freedom, such as the state and the church.
  • Direct action: Each citizen should represent himself or herself, so anarchists rejected political parties and elections.
  • The abolition of private property: Society would be organized into independent communes.

Political Ideologies in 19th-Century Spain: Moderates vs. Progressives

ModeratesProgressives
SovereigntyShared between the monarch and the Cortes, but with royal power strengthenedPopular sovereignty in Cortes and royal power reduced
The CortesBicameral: Congress (elected) and Senate (elected by the monarch)Bicameral: both elected
SuffrageLimited male suffrageLimited male suffrage with lower property requirement
Access to powerThrough elections and royal appointmentThrough military coups
SupportersNobility, Church, wealthy bourgeoisieMiddle and petite bourgeoisie

Key Differences: Marxism vs. Anarchism

MarxistsAnarchists
OrganizationSocialist parties and trade unionsOpposed to political parties but in favor of revolutionary trade unions
Method of protestStrikes and the organization of workers into political partiesAny means, including violence
StateWorking-class controlled stateOpposed to the existence of the state
Means of productionState-controlledDirectly controlled by the working class and peasants

Entradas relacionadas: