Notes, summaries, assignments, exams, and problems for Philosophy and ethics

Roman Law Case Study: Family Status

Case Scenario: Faul and Dercy's Children

Faul, a 28-year-old Roman citizen and sui iuris, marries Dercy, a Greek woman, through confarreatio. A year after their wedding, Dercy becomes pregnant. Faul dies, and eight months later, a boy and a girl are born.

Question: Determine the legal status of each child.

Analysis of Children's Legal Status

In Roman law, an individual's legal status was defined by three key components:

• Status Libertatis (Freedom Status): Whether a person was free or a slave.
• Status Civitatis (Citizenship Status): Whether a person was a Roman citizen, a Latin, or a foreigner (peregrinus).
• Status Familiae (Family Status): Whether a person was sui iuris (independent, not under anyone's power) or alieni

Ortega y Gasset's Theory of Knowledge

In 1916, José Ortega y Gasset distinguished two major periods in the history of thought: the realist and the idealist. Ortega's philosophy critically examines both. Realism, originating from Greek thought, considers a thing as an independent reality, distinct from human perception. It posits that things leave their mark on the mind, imprinting their image like a seal on wax – a concept Ortega termed the "thing-as-substance" metaphor.

Idealism, conversely, discards this notion. It asserts that consciousness finds things, but these things do not emerge into consciousness as external entities. Instead, things are objects of consciousness, which are essentially ideas – a concept Ortega described as the "... Continue reading "Ortega y Gasset's Philosophy: Knowledge, Life, and History" »

Argumentative Composition: Structure and Writing

Understanding Argumentative Composition

• Definition: An argumentative composition requires you to present your opinion on a topic, analyzing both sides by presenting arguments for and against.
• Introduction: This section is very important because it gives the reader the first impression of the text.
• Body: Write the ideas for and against the topic.
• Conclusion: This is also very important. It closes the composition, aiming to convince the reader that your essay has covered all the most important arguments about the topic.

Steps to Write an Argumentative Text

1. Make two lists: one for advantages and another for disadvantages.
2. Decide the order in which you will mention the points or ideas.
3. Plan what to include

Identity and Friendship

Identity

Identity is the awareness of being oneself, unique and unlike any other.

Friendship

Responsibility: A responsible friend acts for the other's good, avoiding harm.

Justice: A true friend doesn't ask for unjust things or engage in abusive behavior.

Solidarity: Friends stand together in good times and bad, sharing joys and sorrows.

Sex, Sexuality, and Family

Sex and Sexuality

Sex: The biological mechanism of reproduction in living beings.

Sexuality: A broader concept encompassing sex and affection.

Family Functions

• Reproductive
• Educational
• Emotional
• Economic
• Healthcare

Parenting Styles

• Authoritative: Demanding, rigid, with limited affection. Often disregards children's feelings and perspectives.
• Assertive: Demanding yet warm. Sets

Kant's Metaphysics of Morals: Imperatives and Duty

This commentary discusses a fragment of Chapter 2 of Kant's Metaphysics of Morals. The text exposes the difference between the hypothetical and categorical imperatives and affirms the latter as the maxim that must become the standard for all men.

The text can be divided into two parts, consistent with Kant's formal ethics. The first part covers the initial paragraphs (concerning the nature of the imperative) and the second part (the third paragraph) expressly states the categorical imperative.

The Distinction Between Hypothetical and Categorical Imperatives

When analyzing the first part, we deduce that an imperative is simply a principle that commands. However, for Kant, this command need not be... Continue reading "Kant's Categorical Imperative and the Foundations of Formal Ethics" »

Hume on Moral Emotivism: Feeling Over Reason

David Hume notes that one cannot rationally prove something is good or bad, because moral issues are not relevant to the understanding. Understanding, according to Hume, can only perform two operations: relating facts or ideas. If moral issues could be treated as relations of ideas, one would arrive at absurd conclusions. For example, describing the behavior of any human (rational or irrational) as good or bad, despite their very different purposes. That is, even a computer could evaluate whether actions are good or bad based on specific parameters.

If we treated moral issues as matters of fact, there would be nothing called good or bad, because the quality of good (or bad) does not inherently belong... Continue reading "David Hume's Philosophy: Morality, Knowledge, and the Mind" »

Nietzsche's Superman: The Path to Self-Overcoming

"In another time, to act against God's delight was the highest delight. But God is dead, and with the dead are also those delinquents! Now, the most horrible crimes are against the land, and it entails the most inscrutable way." This challenging statement, echoing themes from the prologue to Thus Spoke Zarathustra, introduces Nietzsche's profound idea that man is something that must be overcome. Nietzsche describes man as a mediocre herd being (the herd representing a moral concept), miserable, resentful, and unable to live fully. He is a weak and ill being who lacks the strength to confront traditional values. The Superman (Übermensch) stands in stark contrast. He is capable of creating new... Continue reading "Nietzsche's Superman & Will to Power: Core Philosophy" »

Structure of the Ways

The tracks are five formulations with a common scheme in four steps: a fact of experience, the application of the principle of causality, the impossibility of an infinite causal process, and the term of the causal process.

1st: Starting from a fact of experience, movement, understood as the passage from potency to act, the application of the principle of causality leads to the conclusion that nothing can be both mobile and motor simultaneously. "Everything that is moved is moved by another."

2nd: In the world of the senses, there are efficient causes, which are subordinate to each other to produce effects (for the birth of a tree requires land, water, electricity, etc.). Nothing can... Continue reading "Aquinas' Five Ways: Demonstrating God's Existence" »

Ethical Principles and Personal Responsibility

Understanding Freedom

We possess the freedom to act, which can lead to both happiness and sorrow. Authentic freedom applies to oneself and to others.

Acting with Good Conscience

We must always act thoughtfully, considering what to do. The first step to developing conscience is learning to listen.

Criteria for Ethical Evaluation

Ethical decisions are guided by established rules and values.

Defining Attitude

An attitude is the habitual disposition to act in a certain way, in accordance with a particular value.

Freedom: Response and Constructive Action

Freedom is also defined as the ability to respond appropriately and constructively.

The Concept of a Standard

A standard is a rule to be followed, as it determines... Continue reading "Ethical Foundations: Freedom, Conscience, and Human Dignity" »

Nietzsche's Revaluation of the Body and Senses

This text examines Nietzsche's profound critique of how the body and senses, which he argues have been despised and suppressed by the philosophical, moral, and religious traditions of Western culture.

The Philosophical Devaluation of the Body

Nietzsche attributes this decline to philosophers' denial of instincts and the body's senses. He argues that these thinkers reject what is inherently tied to change and plurality. This rejection stems from a static conception of being that, originating with Parmenides, Socrates, and Plato, subsequently dominated the Western philosophical tradition up to modern times.

The Static Conception of Being and Overestimated Reason

This static conception of being arises... Continue reading "Nietzsche's Revaluation of the Body and Senses in Western Thought" »