Admissibility of Illegally Obtained Evidence and Burden of Proof in UK Law
Classified in Law & Jurisprudence
Written on in
English with a size of 2.58 KB
Admissibility of Illegally Obtained Evidence
Michael Doherty states that if a right under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) is infringed due to illegality, the evidence obtained can be excluded. For example, installing a covert listening device in the defendant's home to get a recording of him admitting to crimes would be a breach of the defendant's right to privacy under Article 8(1). However, this evidence was still admissible. Therefore, it is shown that even if the method of obtaining evidence is illegal, the evidence can still be admissible as long as the illegality does not impair the reliability of the evidence obtained.
Nash & Choo also came up with a guideline, as shown in "What's the matter with s.78?" It provides that