Compliance Techniques in Psychology: Foot-in-the-Door, Door-in-the-Face and Lowballing

Psychology and sociologyUpdated on 3.94 KB

Summary

This document introduces three social compliance techniques: Foot-in-the-Door, Door-in-the-Face and Lowballing. It explains how each one increases the chance that a person agrees to a request. It also describes two classic studies, Dickerson et al. (1992) on water conservation and Cialdini et al. (1978) on lowballing, showing how these techniques work in practice.

Key points

  • Foot-in-the-Door (FITD): agreeing to a small request increases the chance of agreeing to a larger one later.
  • Door-in-the-Face (DITF): an unreasonably large request is refused, making a more reasonable second request more likely to be accepted, often because of reciprocity.
  • Lowballing (LB): an initially low price or offer is made, and it is raised after the target's commitment is secured.
  • Dickerson et al. (1992): students who signed a poster and completed a water survey had average shower times of 3.5 minutes, significantly shorter than the dormitory average.
  • Cialdini et al. (1978): 56% of students agreed to participate under lowballing, compared with 24% in the control group.
  • In the Cialdini study, 95% of students who agreed showed up for the 7:00 AM meeting.

Test yourself

Understanding Social Compliance Techniques

Introduction to Compliance Strategies

Foot-in-the-Door (FITD) Technique

  • Getting someone to agree to a small request significantly increases the chance of agreement to a subsequent, larger request.

Door-in-the-Face (DITF) Technique

  • A large, unreasonable offer is made which will surely be turned down; a second, more reasonable offer is then more likely to be accepted (often relying on the principle of reciprocity).

Lowballing (LB) Technique

  • Offering a deceptively or unrealistically low bid.

  • The initial offer is made at a lower price than is actually intended to be charged, and the price is subsequently raised after the target's commitment is secured, often increasing profits.

Dickerson et al. (1992): Foot-in-the-Door Study

Context: Conserving water by taking shorter showers.

  • Aim: To support the effectiveness of the Foot-in-the-Door (FITD) compliance technique in promoting water conservation.

  • Method:

    • The team wanted to see if they could get university students to conserve water in the dormitory showers.

    • To do this, researchers asked them to sign a poster that read: "Take a shorter shower. If I can do it, so can you!"

    • Then they asked them to take a survey designed to make them think about their own water usage and water wastage.

    • Shower times were subsequently monitored.

  • Results:

    • It was found that those students who had signed the poster and completed the water survey (forcing them to think about their own water wastage) had average shower times of 3.5 minutes.

    • This was significantly shorter than the average shower times across the whole dormitory.

  • Conclusion:

    • When participants signed the petition, they felt a sense of commitment to the cause, influencing their subsequent behavior.

  • Connection to FITD:

    • This study demonstrated the use of FITD as participants were asked to sign a poster (the small request) and then take a survey (the larger request).

      • The FITD compliance technique was shown to be effective in making participants save water and take shorter showers.

Cialdini et al. (1978): Lowballing Study

Note: The initial context of chaperoning juvenile delinquents to the zoo is typically associated with DITF, but the following methodology describes the LB study.

  • Aim: To demonstrate the effectiveness of the Lowballing (LB) technique in a university setting.

  • Method:

    • Researchers asked a class of first-year psychology students to volunteer to be part of a study on cognition that would meet at 7:00 AM (Control Group).

    • A second group was asked the same, except they were not initially told the time (Lowball Group).

  • Results:

    • For the first group (Control), 24% of students were willing to participate.

    • For the second group (Lowball), 56% agreed to participate. All participants in this group took part after later being told that the meeting was at 7:00 AM, despite being allowed to withdraw.

    • On the day of the meeting, 95% of students that agreed to participate showed up for the 7:00 AM meeting.

  • Connection to Lowballing:

    • Cialdini's study shows the effectiveness of the LB compliance technique: 56% of students complied with participating in the study when LB was used, as opposed to 24% when LB was not used (Control Group).

Download

PDF Word HTML

FAQ

What is the Foot-in-the-Door technique?

It is a compliance technique in which getting someone to agree to a small request significantly increases the chance they will agree to a larger, subsequent request.

How does the Door-in-the-Face technique work?

A large, unreasonable offer is made that will almost certainly be refused. A second, more reasonable offer is then more likely to be accepted, often because of the principle of reciprocity.

What is lowballing?

Lowballing is offering a deceptively or unrealistically low price or bid. The price is raised after the target's commitment has been secured, often increasing profits.

Test yourself

Flashcards

Click a card to see the answer.

Quiz

1. What is the core idea of the Foot-in-the-Door technique?
2. In the Dickerson et al. (1992) study, what did students sign?
3. What was the average shower time of students who signed the poster and completed the survey?
4. Why is the Door-in-the-Face technique often effective?
5. What percentage of students agreed to participate in the control group of the Cialdini et al. (1978) study?
6. What percentage of students who agreed to participate in the lowball group showed up for the 7:00 AM meeting?
7. What is lowballing?

Questions generated by AI from the document: check the answers against the text.