Obligations in Civil Law: Real Rights vs. Personal Rights and Sources
Summary
This document explains the basic concepts of obligations in law, distinguishing real rights, which apply to a thing against everyone, from personal or credit rights, which link specific individuals. It covers the elements of an obligation, the classification of sources (contract, crime, quasi-contract and quasi-crime), and the division of duties by nature, including strict law, good faith, and perfect and imperfect obligations.
Key points
- A real right directly and immediately applies to a thing and requires respect from everyone, while a personal or credit right is a relationship between two specific individuals.
- An obligation has two subjects: the active subject or creditor, who can demand performance, and the passive subject or debtor, who is bound to perform.
- The direct object of an obligation is giving, doing or providing something; the indirect object is the thing itself, which should be expressible in money to compensate the creditor if the debtor fails.
- Sources of obligations are classified into four groups: contract, crime, and the acts that are not contracts or crimes.
- Strict law obligations come from ancient Quiritarian law and cannot be modified by considerations of justice or equity.
- Good faith obligations may be increased or reduced by the judge on grounds of justice or fairness, whereas perfect obligations are enforceable through legal action.
Obligations
- General obligations
- Real right: It is one that directly and immediately gravitates on a certain thing, and that requires everyone's equal respect, but purely passive.
- Credit or personal law: It is a special relationship between two specific individuals, one of whom may require the other, determined to provide what under common law is due.
Example: Right to ownership, right to credit a sum of money due to us under a loan.
- The requirement: A link right on the necessity compels us to pay for a thing. The creditor is the active subject of the relationship, and the debtor has liabilities. The lender expects or hopes that the debtor complies with what has been committed to.
- Elements of the obligation: It has two subjects, one active and one passive. This means that the obligation has the effect of subjecting each other to a certain degree, taking away some of his natural liberty, and the other by acquiring a certain advantage. The person linked is the debtor or reus (debtor), the owner of the loop is the creditor (creditor).
- Direct object: It is the giving, making, or supplying.
- Indirect object (the thing): It should always be noticeable in money so that if the debtor does not fulfill their promises, the creditor's right will not be dissatisfied, and you can compensate.
- Sources of obligations
- The sources are divided into 4 classes, as they were of a contract with a crime, as a contract or as a crime: The contract represents a convention or a meeting of minds. Crime is an injury unjustly born as of a contract as is caused by a lawful act other than the convention, was born as a crime when the cause is an illegal act that has not been qualified as a crime.
- Division of duties:
a) BY NATURE OF THEIR RELATIONSHIP
- We have civil obligations, Pretoria, of international law and natural. In the active civil or creditor always has an action for the passive part can be coerced and to provide promised or proper behavior. Synallagmatic obligations imperfect, when the conclusion of the contract only required the debtor contracted and sometimes by the development of contract could be also required the creditor synallagmatic perfect, were improved when the contract obligations for both parties emerged
- Strict legal obligations are those that came from ancient right Quiritarian business, in which the debtor was required to contract without reasons of justice or equity may increase or decrease the content of their duty.
- Obligations of good faith, either re perfected by delivery of the object, or by the mere consent of the parties and the scope of the obligation is likely to be increased or decreased for reasons of justice or fairness or the interpretation of the judge to fix responsibilities between the parties.
- Perfect obligations are those provided of action, which allowed the court to force the debtor to creditor compliance.
Download
PDF Word HTMLFAQ
What is the difference between a real right and a personal right?
A real right applies directly to a thing and must be respected by everyone, such as ownership. A personal or credit right is a special relationship between two specific individuals, where one can require the other to provide something due, such as repayment of a loan.
Who are the creditor and the debtor in an obligation?
The creditor is the active subject who holds the right to demand performance. The debtor, also called reus, is the passive subject who has the duty to comply with what was committed.
What is a perfect obligation?
A perfect obligation is one that provides an action allowing the court to force the debtor to comply with the creditor's claim.
Test yourself
Flashcards
Click a card to see the answer.
Quiz
Questions generated by AI from the document: check the answers against the text.