Fetal Personhood and Abortion: Warren vs. George and Lee

Philosophy and ethicsUpdated on 2.04 KB

Summary

This essay compares two positions on whether a six-week-old fetus counts as a person and whether abortion is morally permissible. It presents Mary Anne Warren's five criteria for personhood, which the fetus fails, and George and Lee's view that a human embryo has inherent moral status from conception. The author concludes that George and Lee's argument is more convincing.

Key points

  • Mary Anne Warren lists five conditions for personhood: consciousness and capacity to feel pain, reasoning ability, self-motivated activity, ability to communicate, and self-awareness.
  • According to Warren, an entity that does not fulfill all five conditions cannot be considered a person, so abortion would be permissible.
  • George and Lee argue that abortion is morally wrong because it kills a human being with moral status.
  • George and Lee base their view on the human embryo's blood cells from both parents, human genetic makeup, and status as a complete, immature organism.
  • George and Lee's 'no-persons argument' holds that moral status does not depend on the current stage of development or on acquired qualities.
  • The author judges George and Lee's argument more convincing because it is grounded in scientific evidence about fetal development.

Test yourself

Fetal Personhood and Abortion: A Comparative Analysis

Mary Anne Warren's Criteria for Personhood

Mary Anne Warren would likely argue that a six-week-old fetus does not meet the criteria for personhood. She outlines five conditions necessary for an entity to be considered a person:

  1. Consciousness and the capacity to feel pain.
  2. Reasoning ability.
  3. Capacity for self-motivated activity.
  4. Ability to communicate.
  5. Self-awareness and self-concepts.

According to Warren, if a fetus does not fulfill all five conditions, it cannot be considered a person. Therefore, she would likely support the permissibility of abortion in this case.

George and Lee's Argument for Fetal Moral Status

In contrast, George and Lee would argue that abortion is morally wrong because it involves the killing of a human being with moral status. They base their argument on the premise that a human embryo:

  • Contains blood cells from both parents.
  • Possesses a human genetic makeup.
  • Is a complete, albeit immature, organism.

They contend that personhood is not an accidental attribute but an inherent quality of a human being from the moment of conception. George and Lee's "no-persons argument" challenges Warren's position by asserting that a human being's moral status is not contingent upon their current stage of development or the gradual acquisition of specific qualities.

Analysis and Personal Opinion

George and Lee's argument is more convincing because it is grounded in scientific evidence about fetal development. While Warren's criteria for personhood are thought-provoking, they seem arbitrary and fail to acknowledge the biological reality of a developing human being. The fetus's identity as a human being should not depend on its current capabilities but on its inherent nature as a living organism with the potential for growth and development. Therefore, abortion, especially when the fetus is considered a human being, raises significant ethical concerns.

Download

PDF Word HTML

FAQ

What five conditions does Mary Anne Warren give for personhood?

Warren lists consciousness and the capacity to feel pain, reasoning ability, capacity for self-motivated activity, ability to communicate, and self-awareness and self-concepts. An entity must fulfill all five to be considered a person.

What is George and Lee's main argument against abortion?

George and Lee argue that abortion is morally wrong because it involves killing a human being with moral status. They hold that personhood is an inherent quality present from the moment of conception.

What is the 'no-persons argument'?

It is George and Lee's argument that a human being's moral status does not depend on their current stage of development or on the gradual acquisition of specific qualities.

Test yourself

Flashcards

Click a card to see the answer.

Quiz

1. According to Mary Anne Warren, how many conditions must an entity fulfill to be considered a person?
2. Which of the following is NOT one of Warren's conditions for personhood?
3. When, according to George and Lee, does personhood begin?
4. What is the 'no-persons argument' based on?
5. Which evidence does the author say makes George and Lee's argument more convincing?

Questions generated by AI from the document: check the answers against the text.